A few friends convinced me to try it. While it's an alright game, it really gives me the feeling that it was written by Legend of Zelda developers, rather than Everquest Developers. It's almost like the Nintendo version of Everquest.
I'm probably going to give it a few more days, but so far I haven't seen a lot to convince me to leave EQ1 for it. The combat system's a lot less robust (you basically follow their script on fights, no splitting and minimal choice in how to actually do the fighting). The quests are far too easy (they tell you pretty much everything to do, rather than allowing you to puzzle it out (assuming you don't read up on the quest here, of course!) The graphics are nice, but I just don't see the game really holding me that long. Probably the only way that is going to happen is if most of my friends leave EQ for this, maybe...